Are GLP-1s Killing the Holiday Vibe?
As more and more Americans take the drugs, family tensions are hitting a fever pitch. Here’s how to cope with the weirdness this festive season.
Every year the same rhetorical whiplash happens in the US: Food media goes completely apeshit vying for the very best pumpkin pie recipe to trot out at festive get-togethers. And then, come New Year’s Eve, the cultural conversation gets knocked up with subtext encouraging you to spend January making penance for your indulgences. This season has always managed to surface our longest-held hangups around eating, self-control, and body image. And now, widespread GLP-1 use seems to be transforming our most food-centric family holidays into anxiety-inducing hellscapes, kind of like when you go to a theme park on mushrooms.
“Christmas is coming up, and honestly, I’m wondering what on earth I should be eating this year,” wrote one Reddit user who’d recently started taking a GLP-1. “When I go out to restaurants now, I can barely finish even small portions, which is great for my health [editor’s note: red flag] but kind of awkward during the holidays when everything is about food!” They went on to list all of the rules they planned to follow at parties, including eating protein first, opting for “roasted veggies instead of creamy sides,” and “skipping the heavy starters” to avoid feeling sick later. The thread is filled with responders sharing similar tips and concerns.
At this point, GLP-1 receptor agonist drugs are everywhere. According to a Gallup poll from July of this year, Americans’ use of the injectables for weight loss has nearly quadrupled since 2024, with 15% of the population reporting having taken one of the various medications at some point. (Plus, prescriptions for people with no medical need are also climbing into the millions). For many, the results have been life-changing. The relationship between body fat and health outcomes is muddy, complicated, and rife with harmful biases. Still, when a patient needs to lose weight for a specific medical reason, GLP-1s are often the go-to solution.
At the same time, this sort of steep weight loss appears to be causing rifts in all sorts of relationships. The Washington Post reports that when one partner in a couple starts a GLP, decisions around where to go on a date night suddenly become about so much more than “Pasta or Thai?” (In lieu of specific data, Sam Stone writes for Bon Appétit that bariatric surgeries, which tend to produce comparably dramatic body changes, made couples twice as likely to divorce afterward.) One partner of someone on a GLP-1 told The Guardian they feel “greedy” about their own meal choices now, a friend said they’re tired of talking about little else but food and dieting, and one man’s wife apparently left him for another dude after she’d lost weight.
I think it’s extremely important to acknowledge that so-called “normal” eating is not perfect eating.
Tensions are bubbling. And perhaps nowhere is this relational strain so intense as within families. As Izzy Grinspan writes in Harper’s Bazaar about mothers and daughters taking GLPs, “When you’re used to watching loved ones navigate the world in a body shaped like your own, it can be destabilizing to witness them suddenly change.” While much of the conversation around these medications focuses on the individual patient experience, families are cultural ecosystems. And unfortunately, our relatives are also the people who most powerfully shape our deeply held and often unconscious ideals about beauty, size, and appetite. Even when everyone at the table is a fully grown adult, a family member’s weight loss doesn’t happen in a vacuum.
Here, I chat with Camilla Mager, Psy.D. — a licensed clinical psychologist specializing in eating disorders — about what’s going on with these medications and how we can all thrive at the turkey table this holiday season. Read on for the good stuff, or opt out if it’s triggering.
What is it about family relationships in particular that tend to make body image issues often feel extra loaded or fraught?
Gosh, where to start? I think the bottom line is that your parents are the people you look to for modeling. And either children define themselves as similar to their parents or in opposition to them. So I think a parent’s approval can mean quite a lot to a child.
And going the other direction, a parent looks at a younger child and thinks about all the things they wish they’d done, the mistakes they’ve made, whether they see their kids making the same mistakes or doing something that they would never consider. They can have a sense of, “Gosh, if only I had done X, Y, Z or known X, Y, Z when I was your age.” It doesn’t have to be feelings of full-on envy, but there’s often some degree of “Oh, if only I had…”
Yeah, my mom jokes all of the time that I’m living her dream. What do you think are some of the ways that children develop feelings about their own bodies via their parents?
I mean, as a child, if you hear your mother criticizing her body or saying negative things about her body and whether you happen to look like her or don’t look like her at all, you are going to have a reaction. “Wait, I have the same shoulders as you. So you’re saying your shoulders are bad, so my shoulders are bad.” Or, “Thank goodness I don’t look like you — is my body okay?” Part of parental modeling is also that children inevitably internalize a lot of what they hear. So yes, it’s somewhat inescapable.
I find that problematic, because then you’re just living in the same kind of torturous headspace you were before, even if you’re in a body that society — with all of its biases — deems more acceptable.
What positive or negative psychological consequences have you seen amongst your own patients who are taking these medications?
I think it’s an amazing drug in that there’s no reason you can’t eat cake and also lose weight. But I have seen people not do the work of habituation. What happens a lot of times with binge eating disorder, at least, is that people develop “good” foods and “bad” foods. They still think they’re not supposed to have the “bad” foods, so when they do have even a bite, it tends to cascade into a binge. Amongst other strategies, the way that you get over binge eating disorder is by eating some of the foods that you have deemed as “bad” every day, so that they’re not as exciting.
Sometimes people who go on GLP-1s stay afraid of certain foods. I find that problematic, because then you’re just living in the same kind of torturous headspace you were before, even if you’re in a body that society — with all of its biases — deems more acceptable. But that’s not really the point. The point is to be able to completely overcome the pathology.
In a situation where, say, emotions rise at the Thanksgiving dinner table, what’s the ideal way for families to navigate that?
I am a big believer in having a reasonably calm, respectful conversation where you tell the person the impact of their behavior — specifically on your feelings. For example, “I’m really hurt that you won’t eat the pie that I spent however long baking, and it makes me feel rejected. Even though I know you’re not really rejecting me, you’re rejecting my food, but it feels the same.” And then hopefully the other person can say, “Gosh, I really hear you. I’m so sorry. That’s not my intention. I just can’t stomach that particular flavor of pie right now.”
That’s obviously the ideal, but unfortunately, we all tend to get defensive and that’s part of what leads to a lot of conflict. I don’t think it’s usually our intention to hurt someone else, and that’s kind of all you have to say.
Can you describe a neutral to healthy body image? What does that look and feel like day-to-day when you’re making food decisions, when you’re going about the world?
I think a neutral or accepting body image is the goal; I don’t think body positivity is realistic for most. And I think that looks like some degree of comfort in working with what you’ve got. A neutral view of our bodies isn’t without insecurities. But you’ll appreciate and accept the fact that this is just how you’re built. Ideally, you’ve also gotten to a point where you appreciate your body for what it’s capable of doing — not just its form, but its function.
Eating-wise, it’s about being flexible while also honoring your own preferences and needs. Sometimes you eat because you’re hungry and sometimes you eat for pleasure. I think it’s extremely important to acknowledge that so-called “normal” eating is not perfect eating. Because food is not just food. It’s not just sustenance; it’s also social. And so “normal” eating involves eating with friends and being comfortable going out to dinner, even if you’re not the “right” amount of hungry for whatever that meal is that you’re going to eat.
Generally speaking, what are the most effective strategies for people who are struggling with their body image?
It really depends on the person and how distorted their body image is. But provided you’re up for it, I think that physical activity is incredibly helpful for managing body image issues. Feeling capable in your body is very helpful. But this is contingent on the fact that you’re actually eating enough to sustain the physical activity that you’re doing. It’s also not working out in a gym with a bunch of mirrors. You can’t go watch yourself on a StairMaster for 45 minutes and think you’re going to feel better. Go outside, get some vitamin D, join a league, play a game, have fun.
I’m biased here, but I think therapy can be a helpful tool in looking at why you might be so fixated on your body. A lot of times patients will say, “I feel fat.” And I will respond: “I understand you’re having a somatic experience where it really feels like your body is expanding. That’s not physiologically possible for it to have grown as much as you think it has in the 30 minutes you’ve been sitting here. You’re more likely fat with feeling.” Then we work on whatever emotion has come up and see if that impacts how they’re feeling in their body.
Fat with feeling! Wow, that’s so valid.
Right. And if you can make space and actually process the feeling and not be bowled over by it, shockingly, within about five minutes, suddenly you’re back to your normal weight and experience in your body. So that’s a big one.
For someone who might be on a GLP this holiday season, what are some ways they can respond if food is being pushed on them, or emotions are being projected at them?
Remember who you are, what you feel, and stay grounded in your own truth. Operate from that place — not as a reaction to whatever is being projected upon you or pushed towards you. Stay in contact with yourself as much as possible. Take breaks and go to the bathroom or get up and walk around for a minute or two if you find you’re losing contact with how you want to behave and who you know you are. Try to act rather than react.